Johnny Brewer, a convicted murderer, and Jimmy Causey, a convicted kidnapper, had been on the loose since Tuesday, when they escaped from a Columbia prison. They were apprehended about 110 miles to the south, at a motel along busy Interstate 95 in Ridgeland, said Robert Stewart, chief of the state Law Enforcement Division.
"We got a tip from a local restaurant that had delivered pizza and thought it was suspicious," Ridgeland police chief Richard Woods told CBS News.
Causey and Brewer "were getting to the point they were pretty hungry," Woods said.
Judie Trainer delivered the pizza to the Palms Motel.
"He said, 'I'm in the shower. The money's on the table. Come on in and get it.' I said, 'No, sir.' I kept one foot out this door and one foot in the room and stretched over, got the money. It wasn't enough. I said, 'Sir, I need more money.' He said, 'Well, just a minute, ma'am, and I'll give you $5 more.' He reached around the door. And I had never seen his face. And handed me another five. I took the five out of his hand," Trainer told CBS News Early Show co-anchor Harry Smith.
But Trainer says she knew something wasn't right.
"He said he was in the shower. The arm was dry. The money was dry," Trainer said. "I think I'm very lucky I'm here today."
Trainer called her husband.
"When she said she thought something was up, I told her I agreed with her. I walked over to the police station and got in touch with Chief Woods and told him I thought they ought to check it out," Bill Trainer said.
Judy Trainer will now get a $5,000 reward, "a pretty good tip on a pizza delivery," notes Smith.
Pat Smith, a maid at the motel, said Causey told the clerk when he checked in Tuesday night that his identification was in his car, and that the car had been towed.
"He was real friendly," she said. "When they got (Brewer) in the cuffs, (Causey) said, 'Can I get my money back?' He said, 'Can I get a refund?'" Smith hadn't seen Brewer before his arrest, she said.
The pair had been seen Tuesday after their escape in a car authorities allege was driven by Ashley Bostic, 23, of Hopkins. Richland County authorities charged Bostic on Thursday with harboring an escaped convict.
According to arrest warrants, Bostic confessed to driving Causey and Brewer to Ridgeland to help them get away. The car was recovered Tuesday night in Orangeburg County, between Columbia and Ridgeland.
Steven Blair Goodwin, 26, and Kate Tilley, 21, both of Hopkins, also were charged with obstruction of justice and lying to police. Goodwin is Causey's half-brother.
In 2004, Causey, 35, was convicted of holding Columbia attorney Jack Swerling and his family at gunpoint in their home in 2002. Brewer, 39, was convicted in 1999 for strangling his sister-in-law, Kelly Burbage, in 1994.
They've now learned a valuable lesson, says CBS News correspondent Mark Strassmann: You don't short-change the pizza deliverywoman.